Teardown

Insurance · Deep dive

Lincoln Financial Group

Top-tier US life insurer navigating a defensive reset; Bain Capital took 9.9% equity stake and 10-year investment management role in June 2025.

at risk

Lincoln's strategic position is defensive, not offensive — Bain's capital solves a balance-sheet problem but the ~6-8% ROE and legacy VA block drag make Lincoln a likely acquisition target in the 2028-2030 PE life-insurance consolidation wave.

My take

Revenue
$17.3B (FY2024)
Headcount
~10,000
Screen
Published
2026-11-20
Web
lincolnfinancial.com
Elsewhere
LinkedIn · Crunchbase

Founders and leadership

  • Perry Randall Co-founder (1905)

    Fort Wayne, Indiana businessman who led the founding of Lincoln National Life Insurance Company; licensed the Lincoln name with permission from Robert Todd Lincoln.

  • Ellen Cooper CEO (May 2022–)

    Previously Chief Risk Officer at Lincoln; led the 2022-2025 strategic reset and the Bain Capital partnership.

Snapshot

Lincoln Financial Group (NYSE: LNC) is a top-tier US life insurance and retirement platform — $316B of assets under management, $17B of 2024 revenue, 10,000+ employees. It is the #2 US life insurance underwriter by individual-life sales, a top-five variable-annuity provider, and a major group-protection (STD/LTD/dental) carrier. The company has spent 2023-2026 executing a defensive strategic reset under CEO Ellen Cooper (joined May 2022), culminating in a $825M Bain Capital equity investment at $44/share closed in June 2025 — a 25% premium to the trailing 30-day VWAP but also an implicit acknowledgment that Lincoln needed external capital to shore up a balance sheet stressed by COVID-era mortality losses and legacy variable-annuity blocks (Businesswire, June 2025). The core question: is Lincoln on a path to becoming the next-decade life insurer of record, or is Bain's 9.9% equity stake the start of a longer managed wind-down?

Founding and ownership history

Lincoln Financial's roots date to 1905, when a Fort Wayne, Indiana group led by Perry Randall founded Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, using Abraham Lincoln's name with explicit permission from Robert Todd Lincoln (son) — unusual provenance for a life insurer. The company was built as a mutual, demutualized indirectly through a holding-company restructuring in 1968 (NYSE: LNC), and spent most of its history as a mid-sized life insurer with periodic acquisitions to expand.

Key transactions: 1998 acquisition of CIGNA's individual life and annuity business; 2006 acquisition of Jefferson-Pilot for $7.5B, nearly doubling the company and making it the top-five life insurer. 2008-2010 TARP recipient during the financial crisis (received and fully repaid government assistance). 2018 divestiture of Lincoln Vermont and other non-core blocks.

CEO succession: Dennis Glass served as CEO from 2007 until 2022 — a long tenure that saw the Jefferson-Pilot integration and the 2008 TARP period. Ellen Cooper, previously chief risk officer, took over in May 2022 at an inflection moment: COVID mortality losses had exhausted some mortality margins, the variable-annuity block was underperforming given low-interest-rate hedging, and the equity market was demanding reduced risk exposure.

Bain Capital's 2025 move: on April 9, 2025 Lincoln and Bain announced an $825M strategic growth investment at $44/share, closing in June 2025. The deal was unusual in structure — Bain took 9.9% common equity (just under the regulatory filing threshold) and committed to a 10-year, non-exclusive strategic investment management partnership across private equity, growth, credit, and real assets (Businesswire, June 2025). This is the Apollo-Athene template imported to a mid-cap public life insurer: PE capital plus PE-managed investment portfolio, with the life insurer retaining customer-facing operations.

How it works

Lincoln's revenue engine has three legs: (1) Life Insurance Product Line, which sells individual life policies (term, universal, variable universal) through MGA channels and financial advisors; (2) Annuity Line, which sells variable annuities and fixed indexed annuities through broker-dealer distribution; (3) Group Protection, which sells short-term and long-term disability insurance, group life, dental, and accident/critical illness policies to employers. Across all three, Lincoln underwrites the insurance risk and manages a general-account investment portfolio (~$130B) whose yield generates spread revenue.

The Bain partnership changes the investment-management side: a growing share of Lincoln's general account will be managed by Bain across private credit, private equity, real estate, and alternatives — pursuing 50-100 bps of incremental yield vs. publicly traded fixed income. The operations side — customer service, underwriting, claims — remains Lincoln's. This is specifically the model that has made Athene (the Apollo affiliate) one of the fastest-growing insurers of the last decade.

Product and business overview

Four segments. Annuities (~30% of revenue) — variable annuities, fixed indexed annuities, registered index-linked annuities (RILA). Lincoln has specifically shifted away from guaranteed-income variable annuities (the 2018-2022 problem product) toward RILA products with capital-light risk profiles. 2024 RILA sales were up 33% vs. 2023 (Insurance Business Magazine, 2024).

Life Insurance (~25% of revenue) — individual life: term, universal, variable universal. Lincoln's traditional franchise. ~$650B of life-in-force.

Group Protection (~25% of revenue) — group disability, life, dental, worksite. Employer-focused distribution through brokers and consultants.

Retirement Plan Services (~15% of revenue) — recordkeeping and administration for defined-contribution plans, often bundled with annuity offerings. Smaller than Principal/Voya/Empower.

Other / Legacy (~5%) — legacy fixed annuities, reinsurance arrangements, run-off blocks.

Business model and pricing

Three revenue streams. Fee revenue from recordkeeping, variable-annuity contract fees, and asset management — ~30% of revenue, moderate-margin. Spread revenue from general-account investments supporting fixed annuities, universal life, and in-force variable-annuity policies — ~45% of revenue; margins highly sensitive to interest rates and credit quality. Insurance premium revenue from life, group, and disability underwriting — ~25% of revenue; combined ratios on Group typically 90-95%. Life insurance pricing is bespoke to risk class and is not disclosed; variable annuities carry 100-150 bps of annual fees including M&E and rider charges; group dental runs $25-45 pepm for employer groups.

Traction over time

Metric FY2021 FY2022 FY2023 FY2024 FY2025E
Revenue $19.2B $19.4B $14.5B $17.3B $18.0B
Net income (loss) $1.4B $(2.5)B $(661M) $924M $1.2B
AUM $360B $291B $303B $316B $325B
Invested assets $148B $132B $139B $144B $150B
Employees 10,500 10,500 10,500 10,500 10,000
Market cap (est.) $12B $5.6B $5.9B $5.4B $8B

(Lincoln Financial 10-K, 2021-2024; FY2025 guidance and Q3 2026 release via Morningstar/Businesswire.)

Market analysis

The US life insurance market is ~$160B of annual premium, mature with 1-3% CAGR. The individual-life and variable-annuity segments are 80% of Lincoln's exposure. Variable-annuity sales industry-wide were $56B in 2024 (LIMRA, 2024), up from $47B in 2022 after the interest-rate repricing favored the product. Fixed indexed annuities grew to $93B in 2024 (LIMRA). RILAs are the fastest-growing sub-category, up 50%+ CAGR 2022-2024. Group benefits (STD/LTD/dental/life) is ~$140B growing 4-5%.

The structural force shaping the sector is the PE-insurance consolidation: Apollo's Athene, KKR's Global Atlantic, Brookfield's American Equity Life, Sixth Street's Resolution Life, and now Bain's Lincoln stake all point at the same thesis — publicly traded life insurers are structurally disadvantaged on investment-side returns vs. PE-managed general accounts.

Competitive intel

MetLife (NYSE: MET) — #1 US group benefits; largest overall life insurer. Scale advantage. Market cap ~$55B.

Prudential Financial (NYSE: PRU) — Large-cap life + retirement; ~$1.6T AUM. Competes directly with Lincoln on variable annuities and individual life.

Athene / Apollo (NYSE: APO) — The template for PE-managed life. Athene has grown from $85B to $350B+ AUM since 2016 using PE-managed portfolios.

Global Atlantic / KKR (NYSE: KKR) — Similar PE-owned life model.

Equitable Holdings (NYSE: EQH) — Variable-annuity competitor; also receives AllianceBernstein management.

Unum (NYSE: UNM) — Group disability leader; competes with Lincoln's Group Protection.

New York Life, Northwestern Mutual — Private/mutual life insurers; stable deep-pocketed competitors.

Guardian, MassMutual — Private mutual peers.

Jackson Financial (NYSE: JXN), Brighthouse Financial (Nasdaq: BHF), Corebridge Financial (NYSE: CRBG) — Spinoff variable-annuity-focused insurers; direct Lincoln competitors.

History and evolution

1905: Founded in Fort Wayne, Indiana; name licensed from Robert Todd Lincoln. 1968: Modern NYSE listing. 1998: Acquires CIGNA individual life/annuity. 2006: Acquires Jefferson-Pilot for $7.5B. 2008: Receives TARP; later fully repays. 2017-2022: Low interest rates stress variable-annuity hedging program; mortality losses from COVID (2020-2022). May 2022: Ellen Cooper becomes CEO. 2022-2023: Takes multiple reinsurance writedowns; sells closed blocks; discontinues guaranteed-income VA product. 2024: Returns to profitability; RILA sales up 33%; announces Talcott reinsurance transaction (Finviz, 2024). April 2025: Announces $825M Bain Capital partnership. June 2025: Closes Bain deal, issues 18.76M new shares at $44 (25% premium). 2025-26: Pivot to spread-based earnings continues; portfolio migration to Bain management begins. The primary stumble has been the 2022 crisis — consecutive quarters of large non-cash writedowns on legacy VA blocks crashed the stock from the $70s to the $20s; the Bain deal is the recapitalization.

What people say

The case for. Insurance News Net (Aug 2025) highlighted Lincoln's $688M Q2 2025 profit and the strategic clarity of the Bain pivot. Sell-side consensus moved from Neutral to Buy during 2025 as Bain's investment thesis stabilized the narrative. Credit rating agencies (Moody's, S&P, Fitch) upgraded Lincoln's outlook from Negative to Stable following the Bain capital raise. RILA growth is the quantitative bright spot — a 33% Q4 2024 sales jump shows product-market fit in the fastest-growing annuity sub-category.

The complaints. Bear thesis: Bain's 9.9% stake is a one-time lifeline, not a long-term solution. The legacy variable-annuity block is still a multi-decade drag. Reddit r/investing has active discussions skeptical of whether Cooper's strategic reset can reach pre-COVID ROE levels. Short interest sits ~5% of float. Customer-facing reviews on BBB and Trustpilot for Lincoln's annuity service are mixed (3.0-3.5 star averages) with recurring themes around slow policy service and complex rider terms. The 10-year Bain investment-management agreement is "non-exclusive" — meaning Lincoln could, in theory, work with other asset managers, but in practice the operational integration of Bain's platform locks the economics in.

Outlook: well positioned or at risk?

At-risk. Lincoln is technically "well-positioned" relative to its 2022-2023 trough — but the strategic position is defensive, not offensive. The Bain capital solves a balance-sheet problem (and signals that Lincoln needed outside capital that it couldn't raise cheaply in the equity market), and the business mix shift away from guaranteed-income variable annuities toward RILA and group benefits is the right move. But the question is whether Lincoln has structural advantages to grow faster than life-insurance peers (MetLife, Prudential) with better scale or than Athene/Global Atlantic peers with better investment economics. The current ROE of ~6-8% is well below the 12-14% pre-COVID level, and the path back is multi-year. Credit cycle risk is elevated — Bain's 10-year asset-management agreement is specifically tilted toward private credit, which has outperformed traditional fixed income but is untested in a severe default cycle. The core wager: that Bain's investment platform delivers 75-100 bps of incremental yield, that RILA/group benefits grow faster than legacy VA shrinks, and that Lincoln escapes the mid-cap life-insurance consolidation wave as an independent. The downside case: Lincoln becomes the next KKR/Apollo acquisition target in 2028-2030.

How to attack it

Attacking an incumbent life insurer directly requires regulatory capital that startups cannot raise. But there are three indirect wedges.

Insurtech distribution — Lincoln's distribution is traditional broker/advisor channels. A Ladder, Ethos, or Policygenius-style distribution engine that owns direct customer relationships can underprice Lincoln's AUM-fee loading by 30-50% on new business. Ethos Technologies specifically targets the term-life segment where Lincoln has been losing share since 2020.

Group benefits automation — Lincoln's Group Protection business is a strength, but admin and claims processing is manual-heavy. A benefits-admin startup (think: Mercer-Marsh for small-mid-market) with fully automated underwriting and claims could disintermediate Lincoln's broker channel.

PE-owned life insurance — The direct competitive threat is more Athenes and Global Atlantics. A new PE-backed life insurer with no legacy block and a modern cloud-native stack could attack Lincoln's new-business book without the drag of legacy liabilities. Several PE firms are reportedly in platform-buying mode for exactly this (Bloomberg, 2024).

Biggest exploitable weaknesses: (1) legacy variable-annuity block drag — ~$200B of in-force VA contracts with hedging requirements that will consume capital for 15-20 more years; (2) Group Protection is a strength but Unum and MetLife have scale advantages Lincoln can't match; (3) Bain dependency — if Bain's private-credit returns disappoint over the 10-year partnership, Lincoln's spread revenue underperforms; (4) ROE of 6-8% is a structural investor turnoff that prevents re-rating; (5) distribution through traditional broker channels has highest cost of acquisition in the industry (Oliver Wyman, 2024); (6) consumer life brand recognition is weak — Northwestern Mutual and MetLife out-rank Lincoln on brand awareness surveys (JD Power, 2024); (7) interest rate sensitivity — a rate drop below 3% would stress hedging programs again, though not to 2020-2022 levels.

Adjacent-segment play

The clearest adjacent move for Lincoln itself is further vertical integration with Bain — accelerating the share of general account under Bain management from 20-30% initially toward 50-70% over the 10-year agreement. Embedded life insurance for small businesses — Lincoln's Group Protection channel reaches ~40,000 employer groups; adding a bundled small-business term-life and key-person product sold through the same brokers would increase penetration without new distribution investment. International expansion through reinsurance — Lincoln has been largely US-focused; a reinsurance-driven entry to Asian life markets (Japan, Taiwan, Korea) where Bain has Asia private-credit infrastructure could open adjacent TAM. Private-credit asset-generation platforms — Lincoln could build or acquire origination platforms (e.g., direct corporate lending, asset-backed) to feed its own general account, reducing dependence on Bain and improving spread. A less-attractive adjacent: variable-annuity growth — the category is cyclical and Lincoln's painful experience argues for caution regardless of RILA's current tailwind. Another less-attractive adjacent: large-plan 401(k) recordkeeping — Fidelity, Empower, and Vanguard dominate; Lincoln's Retirement Plan Services has sub-scale and should either acquire or exit.

Sources and further reading

Capital history

DateRoundAmountValuationLead(s)
1905 - — —
1968 - — —
2006 $7.5B — —
2008 $950M — —
2025-04 $825M for 9.9% at $44/share — —
2025-06 18.76M new shares issued — —

Investors / owners: Public shareholders (NYSE: LNC), Vanguard, BlackRock, State Street, Bain Capital (2025–)

Competitive set

  • MetLife (NYSE: MET) — #1 US group benefits; $55B market cap
  • Prudential Financial (NYSE: PRU) — $1.6T AUM; direct VA and life competitor
  • Athene / Apollo (NYSE: APO) — Template for PE-managed life; $350B+ AUM
  • Equitable Holdings (NYSE: EQH) — Variable-annuity peer
  • Jackson Financial (NYSE: JXN) — Variable-annuity spinoff peer
  • Corebridge Financial (NYSE: CRBG) — Variable-annuity peer
  • Unum (NYSE: UNM) — Group disability leader